Are character homes in Inglewood and Hillhurst worth restoring original hardwood floors or replacing?

In most cases, restoring original hardwood in Inglewood and Hillhurst character homes is absolutely worth it — both for the beauty of the wood and the significant cost savings over replacement. These inner-city Calgary neighbourhoods have some of the finest original hardwood floors in the city, often solid oak or fir installed in the 1910s-1940s, and that old-growth lumber is genuinely superior to what is available today.

The hardwood in many Inglewood and Hillhurst homes was milled from old-growth timber with tight, consistent grain patterns that simply do not exist in modern hardwood products. Those trees grew slowly over centuries, producing wood that is denser, harder, and more dimensionally stable than today's plantation-grown lumber. A well-maintained original hardwood floor in a 1920s Inglewood home can be sanded and refinished to look absolutely stunning — the patina and character of century-old wood cannot be replicated with new material at any price.

Refinishing costs $3-$6 per square foot in Calgary, which includes professional drum sanding, edge sanding, staining (if desired), and three coats of oil-based or water-based polyurethane. For a typical 800-1,000 square foot main floor, that is $2,400 to $6,000. Replacing the same area with comparable-quality solid oak runs $6-$10 per square foot installed, or $4,800 to $10,000 — roughly double the cost for a product that is arguably inferior to the original. The math strongly favours refinishing when the existing floor is structurally sound.

The key question is whether the existing hardwood is restorable. Here is what to evaluate: Board thickness matters — original hardwood in these character homes is typically 3/4-inch solid, which can be sanded and refinished 3-5 times over its lifetime. If it has already been refinished several times, a flooring professional can measure the remaining thickness to determine if another sanding is feasible. Structural damage from water, rot, or termites may make sections irreparable — but patching in matching boards is often possible. Severe cupping or crowning that does not flatten out when humidity is corrected may require board replacement in affected areas. Pet stains that have penetrated through the finish into the wood may not come out with sanding and may require board replacement in stained areas.

One caution for pre-1950s Calgary homes: check for asbestos in any existing underlayment, tile, or adhesive before starting demolition or sanding. Many Inglewood and Hillhurst homes had vinyl tile or linoleum installed over the original hardwood at some point, and the adhesive used may contain asbestos. Have it tested before disturbing it.

For resale value, restored original hardwood in Inglewood and Hillhurst is a genuine selling feature — buyers in these neighbourhoods specifically seek character and authenticity. New engineered hardwood, no matter how nice, does not carry the same appeal in a character home context. Find a flooring refinishing specialist through the Calgary Construction Network who has experience with Calgary's heritage homes.

---

Looking for experienced contractors? The Calgary Construction Network connects homeowners with qualified professionals:

• Universal Slate International Inc.
• Onsite Contracting and Electrical Services
• PLATINUM Pool & Spa Services Ltd
• Radon Lab
• UR COWRY CABINETS